Mysql on Windows vs Linux

frank — Fri, 02 May 2008 04:12:56 +0000

I was working on optimizing a Mysql database today and accidentally stumbled upon a benchmarking exercise. The original Mysql database is hosted on a Windows Server 2003. I develop on a Mysql database server running on Ubuntu Linux. The Linux server ran the same query twice as fast as the Windows server without using caching or anything. I know that Linux does I/O caching on its own as well so I even tried running the query after a fresh reboot to rule out that factor. Then I got help from a colleague and started tweaking with the my.cnf/my.ini to make sure they were the same and each time, the results came back about the same. Mysql on Windows was consistently slower than Mysql on Linux.

Then we decided to load the database onto other servers for more data points on this Mysql performance test. We ran the same query returning 429 rows of data with 13 table joins and a couple of sub-queries. All queries were run on the command line client on the servers themselves to avoid network lag.Â All servers are running Mysql 5.0.x.

Results

1. Ubuntu Linux: 0.70 seconds
2. CentOS: 0.78 seconds
3. Windows 2003 Server: 1.40 seconds
4. Windows 2003 Server: 1.42 seconds

Server hardware

1. Ubuntu Linux
AMD ATHLON 64 X2 4200+
2GB DDR400
200GB 7200RPM SATA/150

2. CentOS
Dual Opteron 240
2GB DDR ECC
120GB 7200RPM SATA/300

3. Windows 2003 Server
Dual Xeon
2GB DDR ECC
7200RPM PATA

4. Windows 2003 Server
2 Dual Xeon (4 CPUs)
8GB DDR ECC
3 73GB 10,000RPM SCSI in RAID 5

A followup to the benchmark that clarifies the cause of the differences

Mysql SQL_NO_CACHE Benchmark Problem

frank — Mon, 25 Feb 2008 23:57:00 +0000

I have been trying to benchmark the sql calls to mysql from an application without success. Even when I set the SELECT statement to SQL_NO_CACHE, the results seemed to be still cached. Apparently, Linux does its own caching of disk reads also. That was giving me incorrect benchmark results if I hit the same data twice.

For those using Linux kernel 2.6.16 or higher, you can clear Linux cache with the following command.
echo 3 > /proc/sys/vm/drop_caches

Unfortunately for me, I am stuck on 2.5.xx and will have to figure out another method.

Tech Blog » benchmark

Mysql on Windows vs Linux

Mysql SQL_NO_CACHE Benchmark Problem